

During the season of lent I have been reading and journaling in the book of Lamentations, not a book I had ever read before nor have I ever heard it preached on. The only verse from the book which is ever quoted is from chapter 3, v 22-23 “for his compassions never fail, they are new every morning; great is your faithfulness.” And I had never known the context for this quote so my study has been quite a voyage of discovery.
Lamentations is a poem written shortly after the destruction of Jerusalem and the exile of the people of Judah and the writer, generally credited as Jeremiah, pulls no punches when he describes the devastation of the city and the degradation of her people. Judah has been overthrown by her enemies because of her sins against God, she has been faithless and has become unclean and so she has been completely destroyed, all the treasures of the temple have been looted and the people have been taken into slavery. The poet weeps over the fate of Daughter Judah and describes the torment he feels at witnessing the terrible fate of the city.
Worse than the military defeat, the Lord has “abandoned his sanctuary” and “rejected his altar”, his presence has been withdrawn from the holy place and he no longer speaks through the prophets there. Judah and Israel have been utterly abandoned by the living God, they proved themselves unworthy of him and he has given them over to their enemies to be punished.
In the ruins of the city the poet describes the starvation of the children and the desperation of their mothers. The “hearts of the people cry out to the Lord”, the city repents in ashes and calls to God for help. The poet begs God to hear and answer the cries of the people, he cannot understand how God could allow the suffering he sees before him, women even eating their own children, priests being killed in the sanctuary, terrors and horror all around.
In chapter three the poet describes his feelings, he walks in darkness and dwells with the dead, he cannot escape the horror he has witnessed and his prayers are blocked from reaching the ears of God. “Yet this I call to mind and therefore I have hope: because of the Lord’s great love we are not consumed.” The poet recalls that God has been merciful in the past and that his love and mercy are new every morning, he clings therefore to the hope that, if he bears his suffering and holds onto his faith in the Lord, he will be shown compassion. The people cannot complain about their punishment for they have deserved it, but if they hold on to their faith and confess their sins, they can hope for compassion and forgiveness.
Chapter 4 returns to the themes of destruction and famine, terrible images of cannibalism and degradation, the humiliation of their sins being revealed, the shame of the slavery now imposed on them. Finally, though, the poet again sounds a note of hope, “your punishment will end Daughter Zion”, he pleads in chapter 5 for the Lord to remember his people, to accept their repentance for the sins committed against him, he proclaims the greatness of the Lord and asks for his people to be restored to their relationship with him.
This has been a very hard book to read, the idea of a loving God who will allow a whole nation to be destroyed and taken into slavery, the images of mothers eating their children, are really difficult to square with the image of Jesus on the cross. Why is God so harsh with Judah? How can a good God allow such dreadful things, not only allow but actually decree them? These are questions we ask every day, not because we are faced with starving or cooking our children, but because there are always things in our lives, on the news, in our relationships with others, which make us question – where is God in this? How is this allowed to happen to me?
The degree of severity does not diminish the feeling of injustice when we feel we have been unfairly treated or when we see the dreadful things which happen every day, wars, famines, natural disasters etc.. We want a simplistic faith where good people get good things and where we can see the wicked are the ones who suffer, we want to be safe from harm, protected against anything that can hurt us, we feel entitled to have a good life. But where does that come from? Not the bible, nowhere in the bible are we promised a life free from difficulty, in fact Jesus promises us the opposite “take up your cross” does not mean come and have a nice time! Paul talks about being pressed but not crushed, persecuted not abandoned, he describes himself as being poured out like water; Stephen preaches the gospel while he is being stoned to death and throughout history we see many saints follow his example. So where did we get the idea that bad things should not happen to good people?
Who said we were good people, come to that, for we all have sinned and fallen short of the glory of God, none of us can stand on our own righteousness and claim that we do not deserve to suffer!
Reading Lamentations I am reminded that everything I have that is good in my life is a blessing from God, that I did not earn or deserve. I know that my sins are as filthy in His eyes as those of Judah and that my need for repentance is as great. I also know, as did the poet, that the Lord I serve is a loving God, full of compassion, and that he will hear my cries and lift me up. I have the advantage of being under the new covenant, where my sins are covered by the blood of Jesus and I have the Holy Spirit to help and guide me, to convict me when I need to repent and to strengthen me against temptation.
Lamentations has also reminded me that the enemy is the father of lies and that his greatest lie is that I am a good person who does not deserve to have troubles in my life. Believing that lie leads to pride, judgement and bitterness against God and too many times that lie is spoken over Christians so that we come to feel entitled to something Jesus never promised us and we resent him for not giving it to us. That lie is at the heart of so many broken relationships and the root of such bitterness, we want to believe the lie because it is easier than the truth, we want the simple solutions but the truth is life does not work like that. Hard truths contained in Lamentations are so much more valuable than all the easy lies in the world, because the truth is what will set us free.